A Happy Workforce Means Greater Profits

Starbucks Should Welcome Union Labor: Introduction

Starbucks Should Welcome Union Labor! Union labor has long been a cornerstone of fair employment practices, especially in industries where workers often face exploitative conditions. For Starbucks, a global coffee giant that prides itself on community values, embracing union labor could enhance its reputation, strengthen its workforce, and improve operational efficiency. Here are five compelling reasons why Starbucks—and companies like it—should welcome union labor, supported by concrete examples that illustrate these benefits.

1. Union Labor Drives Employee Retention and Loyalty

Starbucks Should WELCOME Union Labor

Unionized workplaces see significantly lower turnover rates. For example, in 2022, unionized staff at a Buffalo Starbucks location reported improved communication with management and fair scheduling practices after unionization efforts began. Higher retention saves companies money in recruitment and training costs.

Another example comes from the United Auto Workers (UAW) in Detroit. The UAW negotiated consistent healthcare benefits, keeping employees invested in long-term careers with their employers. Starbucks, which faces high turnover rates among baristas, could similarly reduce attrition by collaborating with unions to address concerns like inconsistent hours and stagnant wages.

2. Collective Bargaining Promotes Fair and Transparent Policies

Unions create a formal structure for addressing grievances and improving policies. For instance, in 2021, unionized employees at REI in SoHo, New York, successfully negotiated more predictable work schedules, which significantly reduced burnout. Starbucks could follow this model to address employee complaints about fluctuating schedules and limited hours. Another reason that Starbucks should welcome union labor.

Additionally, the Communications Workers of America (CWA) negotiated robust protections against unfair treatment for workers in the telecommunications sector. This structure prevented arbitrary decisions and fostered trust. For Starbucks, adopting such practices would reduce costly litigation, like the recent lawsuits over alleged retaliation against unionizing baristas.

3. Unions Enhance Starbucks’ Reputation as a Socially Responsible Brand

Brands that support labor rights often enjoy stronger public support. For instance, Patagonia’s ethical stance on employee treatment has made it a favorite among socially conscious consumers. Starbucks could bolster its image by aligning its practices with its stated mission to support communities and sustainability.

Similarly, Ben & Jerry’s has a long history of working with unions to provide equitable pay and benefits. This partnership has enhanced its brand loyalty, particularly among younger, values-driven customers. Starbucks’ support of unions could strengthen its appeal to similar demographics and restore faith in its ethical branding. Starbucks should welcome union labor and go back to the business of serving coffee to their customers or risk the consequences of people like me who support union labor above company exploitation. But we are in Late Stage Capitalism after all.

4. Union Labor Encourages Operational Excellence

Unionized workers often perform better due to enhanced training and a greater sense of job security. For example, at Kaiser Permanente, a healthcare company with strong union representation, employees report higher engagement and productivity due to clear communication channels and negotiated training programs.

Starbucks could implement similar initiatives to ensure baristas are well-trained and supported. Another example is the airline industry, where unions like the Association of Flight Attendants (AFA) advocate for both worker and customer safety. Baristas who feel valued could offer a superior customer experience, directly benefiting Starbucks’ bottom line.

5. Unions Mitigate Long-Term Costs for Employers

Union partnerships reduce long-term financial risks by preventing expensive lawsuits and strikes. For instance, after Walmart faced public backlash and lawsuits over alleged labor violations, it spent millions on damage control. By contrast, Costco, which embraces union labor, has consistently ranked as one of the most profitable retail chains due to its loyal, well-compensated workforce.

Starbucks, currently facing numerous NLRB complaints, could avoid similar expenses by negotiating fair contracts with unions. Supporting union labor would demonstrate a commitment to stability, reducing costly legal battles and boosting investor confidence.

Conclusion: A Partnership for Prosperity

Starbucks’ current approach to unions—spending millions on anti-union campaigns and legal battles—contradicts its values and harms its workforce. Embracing union labor would yield long-term benefits: happier employees, stronger community ties, and a more profitable operation. Employers like Starbucks should recognize that unions are not adversaries but partners in creating a fair and thriving workplace.

By choosing collaboration over conflict, Starbucks can lead a new era of corporate responsibility, transforming the coffee industry while staying true to its ethical principles. Supporting unions isn’t just good for baristas—it’s good for business.

Sources Cited

National Labor Relations Board (NLRB). (2024). Starbucks labor dispute case documentation.

“REI Union Efforts Win First Contract.” (2021). Communications Workers of America.

Greenhouse, S. (2019). Beaten Down, Worked Up: The Past, Present, and Future of American Labor.

Patagonia. (2023). Ethical labor practices and brand strategy.

“Costco vs. Walmart: A Labor Comparison.” (2022). Economic Policy Institute.

Suggestions for Further Reading

Beaten Down, Worked Up: The Past, Present, and Future of American Labor by Steven Greenhouse
A detailed history of labor movements in the U.S. and their ongoing relevance.

Why Unions Matter by Michael D. Yates
Explores how unions create better workplaces and communities.

Raising the Floor: How a Universal Basic Income Can Renew Our Economy by Andy Stern
Examines labor equity and innovative reforms.

The Big Squeeze: Tough Times for the American Worker by Steven Greenhouse
A critical look at the challenges American workers face in modern industries.

The Labor Movement and the Great Society by Irving Bernstein
Historical insight into labor’s influence during transformative U.S. policies.

Labor Rights as Human Rights by James A. Gross
Argues for the moral case of treating labor rights as universal human rights.

Unions in America: A Reader edited by Gerald Friedman
A curated collection exploring unions’ past and future.

The Case for the Green New Deal by Ann Pettifor
Discusses labor’s role in combating climate change and economic inequality.

The Next Shift: The Fall of Industry and the Rise of Health Care in Rust Belt America by Gabriel Winant
Examines shifting labor landscapes and their implications for policy.

DISCLAIMER: The images on this page, and across the whole blog are created using AI imaging and are intended to illustrate the argument in the post. They are NOT representing real people or events directly, rather the images enhance the argument and nothing more. We do not intend any offense, nor do we wish to single out individuals in any way by the images themselves.