Advocate Health’s Exploitation of the Vulnerable: A Broken Promise (Part 2)

Introduction: A Broken Promise (Part 2)

A Broken Promise (Part 2) explores the behavior of one Healthcare provider, Advocate Health. The healthcare industry often justifies its exorbitant costs by pointing to the quality of care provided, yet the reality reveals a starkly different picture for many Americans. Hospital systems like Advocate Health, which markets itself as a community-centered, faith-based organization, demonstrate how corporate greed has infiltrated even the most altruistic-seeming institutions. Advocate Health, affiliated with the United Church of Christ, exemplifies how promises of care can morph into systemic abuse, disproportionately targeting the uninsured and underinsured. This behavior starkly contradicts the words of Christ, who called for compassion and care for society’s most vulnerable.

The Aggressive Overcharging Epidemic

Advocate Health has become notorious for its exorbitant pricing of medical procedures. For example, a simple MRI scan that costs $500 to $1,000 at independent imaging centers can escalate to tens of thousands of dollars within Advocate Health facilities. Insured patients often see inflated bills due to opaque agreements between the hospital system and insurance providers, but the uninsured and underinsured face the worst of it. These individuals, unable to negotiate prices or defer costs through insurance, are routinely hit with the full, unadjusted rate—a sum that could devastate their finances for years.

Even worse, Advocate Health has been implicated in using its non-profit status to shield massive financial gains while pursuing ruthless debt collection practices. According to several reports, patients with modest incomes have been billed for procedures at three to five times the market rate and then subjected to aggressive collections tactics, including wage garnishment, bank account levies, and lawsuits.

Harassment of Those Least Able to Pay: A Broken Promise (Part 2)

The irony of Advocate Health’s practices lies in its ownership by the United Church of Christ, a denomination that professes dedication to justice and equity. Christ’s teachings urge care for the poor and admonish exploitation of the vulnerable, yet Advocate Health’s behavior exemplifies the opposite. Numerous testimonies reveal how the system harasses those least able to pay: uninsured single mothers, elderly individuals on fixed incomes, and young workers saddled with student loans. These groups often face daily calls from debt collectors or threats of legal action that compound their stress and despair.

A System Designed to Exploit

Advocate Health’s practices reflect broader issues within the healthcare system, but aligning with a faith-based organization makes its behavior particularly egregious. By leveraging its charitable status, Advocate Health can receive millions in tax breaks annually while avoiding scrutiny for its profit-driven practices. Instead of using these savings to subsidize care for low-income patients, the hospital system prioritizes capital projects, executive bonuses, and marketing campaigns to bolster its public image.

Living Contrary to Their Mission: A Broken Promise (Part 2)

Christ’s teachings leave no room for ambiguity when serving the poor and afflicted. The Gospel of Matthew quotes Him: “Truly I tell you, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did for me.” The United Church of Christ, Advocate Health’s owner, ostensibly grounds its mission in this principle. Yet the hospital system’s behavior suggests a deeper allegiance to profit margins than moral obligations.

Consider the case of a young father who sought emergency care for a severe allergic reaction. Without insurance, he was billed over $30,000 for a single visit, including $8,000 for an epinephrine injection that costs $30 at retail. When he explained his inability to pay the bill, Advocate Health’s response was to sue him for the entire amount. Despite his repeated pleas, he was forced into bankruptcy, an experience that left his family homeless for several months.

A Call for Accountability

The time has come to hold institutions like Advocate Health accountable for their role in exacerbating the healthcare crisis. Their actions not only harm individuals but also betray the values they claim to uphold. Faith-based ownership does not excuse greed, and hospitals operating under the banner of care must live up to their promises. Transparency in billing, fair pricing practices, and meaningful financial assistance programs should be non-negotiable standards for all hospital systems.

Advocate Health and its parent organization, the United Church of Christ, must confront a crucial question: Will they continue to perpetuate systemic exploitation, or will they return to the values of compassion, humility, and care for the least among us? Until then, their promises of care will remain nothing more than hollow words.

Suggestions for Further Reading

“The Price We Pay” by Dr. Marty Makary
A scathing critique of the U.S. healthcare system, exploring how institutions exploit patients and proposing solutions for reform.
“An American Sickness” by Elisabeth Rosenthal
This book delves into the structural greed of healthcare and explains how to navigate and counteract it.
“Jesus and the Disinherited” by Howard Thurman
A profound reflection on Christ’s teachings about social justice, offering a stark contrast to Advocate Health’s practices.
“The Healthcare Fix” by Laurence J. Kotlikoff
A look at the economic inefficiencies of the current system and proposals for equitable solutions.

DISCLAIMER: The images on this page, and across the whole blog are created using AI imaging and are intended to illustrate the argument in the post. They are NOT representing real people or events directly, rather the images enhance the argument and nothing more. We do not intend any offense, nor do we wish to single out individuals in any way by the images themselves.

Posts You May Like

7 Examples of Profits Over Patients: A Blunder

10 of Neo-Liberalisms Betrayals of Its Lofty Promises