How the Trump Trade Wars and Costs Could Reshape American Agriculture

—

Introduction: 5 Dire Warnings for American Agriculture

5 Dire Warnings for American Agriculture explores the condition of American agriculture in the face of the promised Trump policies on foreign trade, tariffs, and the threat of a trade war with China and the world.

The U.S. agricultural industry faces a perfect storm of challenges. A bumper crop season, elevated input costs, and shifting global trade dynamics create a grim outlook for farmers. This potential crisis not only threatens their livelihoods but could also transform the agricultural landscape for years to come. The industry’s struggles reveal broader lessons rooted in historical shifts in policy, global trade, and technological advancement. Understanding these five dire warnings is crucial for farmers and policymakers alike.

1. Economic Pressures Crush Farmer Profits

The first of 5 Dire Warnings for American Agriculture. Farmers in the Midwest are grappling with one of the worst financial projections since the 1980s. Despite historic harvests of corn and soybeans, crop prices have plummeted. Agricultural economists estimate that average Illinois farms may incur a staggering $30,000 loss in 2024. The national break-even price for corn, $5.67 per bushel, far exceeds the $4.43 market price, while soybeans face similar gaps.

This echoes the farm crisis of the 1980s when a confluence of high interest rates, falling commodity prices, and aggressive lending policies led to widespread bankruptcies. Back then, the government encouraged farmers to “get big or get out,” pushing them to borrow heavily for modernization. When export markets collapsed due to global recession and trade disputes, many farmers could not repay loans. The echoes of that era reverberate today as farmers face similarly razor-thin profit margins.

2. Trump’s Tariffs Threaten Export Markets: 5 Dire Warnings for American Agriculture

The second of 5 Dire Warnings for American Agriculture addresses the potential tariffs from Donald Trump that could devastate U.S. farmers by targeting key trade partners. Trump’s proposed 20% tariffs on imports, including a 60% tariff on Chinese goods, could spark a trade war. China, Canada, and Mexico—the top importers of U.S. agricultural goods—account for significant export percentages: 16% for corn and 40% for soybeans.

During the 2018 U.S.-China trade war, China diversified suppliers, heavily investing in Brazilian agriculture. Brazil’s soybean production expanded by the equivalent of Kansas’s land area, positioning it as a dominant global player. This scenario mirrors the 1970s U.S.-Soviet grain embargo. When the U.S. banned grain exports to the Soviet Union after it invaded Afghanistan, other countries stepped in to fill the gap. Over time, these embargos eroded U.S. dominance in global grain markets, a loss that farmers felt for decades.

3. Global Oversupply Creates Persistent Price Pressures: 5 Dire Warnings for American Agriculture

Global oversupply worsens the plight of U.S. farmers. While the U.S. harvested record crops, Brazil expanded its output by planting soybeans and corn. This double-cropping capability accelerates global competition, particularly as Brazil has millions of unused acres ready for cultivation.

The situation mirrors the 1990s, marked by the “Freedom to Farm Act,” which removed production limits and encouraged planting for maximum yields. The resultant oversupply led to prolonged low commodity prices, forcing many small and medium-sized farms to consolidate or sell out. Now, history appears to be repeating itself as oversupply from South America creates similar pressures, reducing U.S. farmers’ ability to compete globally.

4. Farmers May Adapt but at a Cost: 5 Dire Warnings for American Agriculture

In response to mounting challenges, farmers increasingly cut expenses. Many switch to generic brands for seed and fertilizer, delay machinery purchases and downsize operations. While these adaptations mitigate losses, they also strain the broader agricultural economy. Companies like John Deere, Corteva, and Nutrien face declining revenues as farmers tighten budgets.

Historically, farmers have faced similar dilemmas. During the Great Depression, plummeting crop prices led to massive farm foreclosures. Farmers banded together in cooperatives to pool resources and survive. Although these efforts helped mitigate individual losses, they underscored the systemic vulnerability of agriculture to economic downturns. Today, farmers find themselves once again making difficult decisions to adapt to external pressures, even as those decisions reshape their industry. In 5 Dire Warnings for American Agriculture, we won’t sugarcoat the potential for disaster.

5. Uncertain Export Future Amplifies Risk: 5 Dire Warnings for American Agriculture

Even with recent upticks in export sales, the future looks precarious. Importers may stockpile U.S. crops temporarily, taking advantage of low prices. However, competition from South America and potential trade wars could redirect demand elsewhere. Without strong export demand, farmers face an uphill battle to achieve profitability.

This mirrors the post-World War II era when the Marshall Plan created new markets for American grain. As Europe rebuilt its agricultural sector, demand for U.S. exports dwindled. Farmers had to adjust to reduced export opportunities, spurring technological innovation and shifts in production practices. Similarly, today’s farmers must navigate an uncertain future where export markets could shift permanently away from U.S. dominance.

Conclusion

The U.S. agricultural sector stands at a crossroads. Farmers face economic, political, and global market pressures that could reshape the industry. History shows that similar crises have had lasting impacts, from the farm foreclosures of the 1980s to the export challenges of the 1970s and beyond. Policymakers must act to address these challenges by fostering fair trade, supporting innovation, and safeguarding the future of American farming.

Sources Cited

Sterling Smith, Independent Commodities Researcher

University of Illinois and Ohio State University Agricultural Economists

U.S. Department of Agriculture

Suggestions for Further Reading

“The Omnivore’s Dilemma” by Michael Pollan – Explores the impact of agricultural policies on food systems.

“Fast Food Nation” by Eric Schlosser – Examines the interplay between agriculture and consumer culture.

“The End of Plenty” by Joel K. Bourne Jr. – Investigates global food security challenges.

“Merchants of Grain” by Dan Morgan – Chronicles the rise of global agribusiness giants.

“Silent Spring” by Rachel Carson – Highlights the environmental impacts of agricultural practices.

“The Fate of Food” by Amanda Little – Looks at innovations shaping the future of farming.

“The Farm Crisis” by John Frahm – Details lessons from the 1980s agricultural collapse.

“Globalization and Agriculture” by Guy Robinson – Discusses trade’s effects on farming economies.

“Agricultural Trade and Policy” by Tim Josling – Analyzes the intersection of trade and farming.

DISCLAIMER: The images on this page, and across the whole blog are created using AI imaging and are intended to illustrate the argument in the post. They are NOT representing real people or events directly, rather the images enhance the argument and nothing more. We do not intend any offense, nor do we wish to single out individuals in any way by the images themselves.